Teacher Notes · Railways or Roads
Target IELTS 6.5–7 · B2 · Authentic published Cambridge material
Task interpretation
The student must judge the proposed preference between the two forms of public investment. Agreeing, disagreeing or qualifying the preference can all work. Assess the quality and consistency of the argument rather than the opinion chosen.
Language activity answers
- Railways are often useful on busy routes. Correct agreement and qualify the absolute claim; accept other accurate revisions.
- Although roads are necessary, rail needs investment. Remove “but”, or remove “although” and keep “but”.
- The government should invest more money in trains.
Feedback checklist
Review Task Response, Coherence and Cohesion, Lexical Resource, and Grammatical Range and Accuracy using the official descriptors. Identify one strength and two priorities, supported by examples from the student’s essay. Do not award a score solely from a word count or a checklist.
Check whether both body paragraphs actually support the stated position. Ask for an explanation wherever an idea is asserted without development. Encourage accurate, appropriate vocabulary and controlled sentence variety.
Original illustrative essay
This model was written for EnglishDrills. It has no official IELTS band rating and is not a Cambridge candidate response. Reveal it after the student attempts the task.
Public transport and road networks both require substantial public investment. I partly agree that railways should receive priority: they can provide an efficient solution on busy routes, but road funding remains essential for communities that cannot realistically be served by trains.
Rail investment is particularly valuable where large numbers of people travel between the same destinations. In such places, a reliable service can offer an alternative to driving and allow passengers to avoid congested streets. For example, a commuter railway connecting residential areas with a city centre may carry people who would otherwise make separate car journeys. However, the benefit depends on practical details. Services must be frequent, stations accessible and fares affordable. Building an impressive line without addressing these conditions may do little to change travel habits.
Roads nevertheless perform functions that railways cannot always replace. People in small, scattered settlements still need access to schools, health services and shops, even where the number of potential passengers would not justify a railway. Businesses also depend on road connections for the final stage of many deliveries. In these circumstances, maintaining an existing road can be a more practical use of public money than constructing new rail infrastructure. This does not mean continually expanding highways; investment can instead address dangerous junctions, damaged surfaces or missing local connections.
Overall, I support prioritising rail on corridors where it can serve substantial demand, while protecting the funding needed for essential road access and maintenance. Governments should therefore compare the needs of each area rather than adopt a universal rule favouring one form of transport.
Verify the published question on IELTS.org ↗