Follow your teacher’s instructions. Your answers save in this browser as you work. Download them to share with your teacher.
B Reading
Read both texts. Answer questions 1–8. Use a short answer where no options are shown.
Text 1 | A room with no queue
The board’s decision to close the enquiry desk was presented as a modest recognition of changed habits. The room, we were told, had been empty for months. I believed it. I had gone there twice myself and found nobody waiting. It occurred to me only later that on both occasions a volunteer had been standing outside the building, helping visitors submit the online form on a shared tablet. Anyone she helped counted as a digital enquiry. The waiting room had indeed been empty. The sentence had the merit of being true.
Some defenders of the closure now say the volunteer proves the new arrangement works. They have a point, though perhaps a less economical one than they intend. The more convincingly they show that the assistance was essential, the less convincingly they can use the figures to show that no one needed it. This would be a familiar argument about the limits of a metric if the people in question were still counted somewhere as people receiving help. In the present records, their independence is inferred from the box that gets ticked after someone has helped them.
I would hesitate to reopen the desk simply to correct the story we tell about its closure. It may have been expensive or difficult to reach. The point is that an empty chair cannot settle a question about the work being done beside it. Before the board calls the transition complete, it should find out where that work went, who now does it, and who manages when nobody does.
Text 2 | From the board secretary’s proposed minute
Recorded use of the enquiry desk fell to a level at which its closure was financially defensible. No reduction in access has been identified through the available reporting channels. To the extent that on-site assistance remains necessary, this is to be provided within existing arrangements. The transition will be reviewed after six months. The review will distinguish demand for staffed space from demand for assistance, insofar as the current records permit. If the board wishes to obtain evidence beyond those records, a separate collection process will require approval.